I've been thinking about wings recently. I love fantasy art, and I don't normally expect it it to be realistic - if it were, it wouldn't be fantasy.
But I seem to be turning into a cranky codgeress on the subject of wings.
Badly drawn ones. Angels with a one-foot wingspan, gryphons whose wings are vague half-circles of fluff, Pegasus with little triangular wings like feathered fins, firebirds with an inverted V of bone hung with a bunch of separate feathers like socks on a washing line.
Real wings have a coherent shape, a structure of bone and muscle, and different kinds of feathers at different parts of the wings for a REASON. Lots of reasons. And I wish more fantasy artists paid attention to this, whether they study anatomy, copy from a stock photo, or use a tutorial like
cedarseed.deviantart.com/art/D…. (Do you have a favorite bird/wing tutorial?)
I know this is silly of me. You shoulda seen the first wings *I* used to draw. And we all have a right to be beginners, and a right to draw our art the way we want to at any age.
And I also know it's silly of me to talk about realism because, well, in the real world winged people and horses are scientifically impossible. For a large mammal to grow wings big enough to support their weight, the wings would add enough more weight of bone and muscle that the creature would need BIGGER wings to lift themselves, which would add MORE weight, and so on. Can't be done.
But I'm still irrationally cranky about badly drawn wings.
For two reasons.
One is, well, fantasy. I WANT to suspend my disbelief in gryphons. I love gryphons. I want them to be real. So if you draw them with realistic wings - wings like a real bird's wings, and in about the same proportion to the rest of the body, my mind can trick itself into almost believing they could be real. But if an artist draws wings that NOTHING could fly with - or wings so small they couldn't even take the weight of the gryphon's head, much less their bodies, I can't suspend disbelief at all.
And the other reason is art. Birds' wings are elegant. The shape of the whole wing, the shape of each feather, the patterns that the feathers make together.... A well-drawn wing is a thing of beauty. Most fluffy half-circles or stubby triangles with feathers aren't. And I'm a selfish viewer and want to see beautiful wings. So there.
-- Nonie
PS: Yes, I know DevArt has some great gryphon artists who draw realistic, well-thought-out, and lovely lovely wings. And I love them like a loving thing for teh WIN! I'm just cranky about everybody else.
PPS: Including me.